I realized two things:
1. There really is Facebook for Teachers!
2. While both have basically the same features, they are set-up very differently!
Take a look at what I mean:
Why Schoology?
Edmodo felt overwhelming to me not only the first time I logged in, but each time thereafter. One thing I did like about Edmodo was the Snapshot feature (generated Common Core based quizzes which the system grades for you). I feel that this would be beneficial in the classroom to see where students are in regards to certain standards and results would guide me with lesson planning in order to meet the needs of all students.
Why Edmodo?
The choice is yours, what works best for you, your students, your classroom, your school, your community? You may choose to use certain pieces of both, however, that may become challenging.
All that being said, I will definitely use one of these sites in the classroom and in labs to get students engaged and involved in their learning. However, I know that the reality is that some students/families/homes (yes, even in this technology driven world) do not have computers or internet access. I will not use either one of these as my only communication, grading, quiz, or assignment tool. I do not feel that it is fair to ask/expect students and families to have to go somewhere else nightly to complete assignments. I want to be sure that I know my students and families and that they all feel welcome and comfortable with the activities and communication in (and out of) the classroom.